
UK needs more referenda for a
strong democracy: BUT quality is crucial
With about a year to run
until the UK is programmed to leave the European
Union, some have begun to think about how we
could improve our governance and democracy. The
turbulent, seemingly chaotic progress of
"brexit" and the amateurish, not too democratic
performance of our pro-brexit politicians may
well have provoked such considerations.
A headline in The Independent reads,
"We still need referendums for a strong
democracy, whatever you thought of the Brexit
result".
Similarly in a regional paper,
"FAIR POINT: Let's hold more referendums,
including a second one on Brexit" Worcester
News
INIREF comments:
The UK certainly has a "flawed
democratic system". Introducing elements
of direct democracy would improve it.
Incidentally, the term "direct democracy" is
often used too loosely – a procedure such as
such as the June 2016 ballot about the EU has
been termed an "authorities' plebiscite". The
"authorities" decided to hold a referendum for
their own purposes, they set the question and
timing and defined the franchise – a weak form
of democracy, really only a consultation. In
direct democracy, formal proposals come from the
electorate. Public proposals for, say, policy or
matters of constitution, emerge from public
discourse and debate, then one or more of these
proposals gets put forward in an effort to
gather support. (Formal rules are needed, a
public electoral body monitors and manages).
There is competition among different proposals.
Only after a large, agreed number of voters,
citizens, have endorsed a proposal can it go
forward for, usually, debate in parliament and
then on to referendum /ballot. The procedures
of public proposal to endorsement to debate
and decision are sovereign acts of (self-)
governance. The whole electorate, in this way,
can steer, guide, correct and over-rule any
other body including political parties,
parliament and government. (Parliament, even in
the United Kingdom, has via elections only
borrowed sovereignty from the people).
Campaign for direct democracy in Britain
Citizens' Initiative and Referendum I&R ~ GB
http://www.iniref.org/
Link to site index
Contact: info@iniref.org